And the winner of our pumpkin pie challenge is...
Sky-high pumpkin pie
Pumpkin pie photos
Congratulations to our winner!
Marg Olsen took on our sky-high meringue — and it was "a big hit at dinner!" It's a hit here too, congrats Marg!
Traditional pumpkin pie
cookma24 takes us up close to her pumpkin pie in this shot, showcasing lovely golden pastry.
Traditional pumpkin pie
Catherine Micallef uses a fun play on words (we love it!) to decorate the top of her pumpkin pie.
Traditional pumpkin pie
Karina Tetrault bakes up a storm, making two large pies for our challenge!
Traditional pumpkin pie
Katie tells us this was her first pumpkin pie from scratch — way to go!
Traditional pumpkin pie
Camille Schram got creative and made her pumpkin pie with a walnut-strudel topping, yum!
Traditional pumpkin pie
Olga Petrik had to snap her picture in a flash — it was was gone quickly!
Traditional pumpkin pie
Karen roasted and puréed a pumpkin from scratch (we're impressed!), and used a 3rd generation family recipe for her traditional pumpkin pie.
Traditional pumpkin pie
The Blissful Culinarian whipped up our traditonal pumpkin pie — it's a family favourite.
Traditional pumpkin pie
Sandy B Matos made individual pies, so "at Thanksgiving, everyone enjoyed their very own mini pie!"
Traditional pumpkin pie
Bonnetea took on our sky-high pumpkin pie challenge — and says it was "even better the next day (after being chilled overnight).
Traditional pumpkin pie
MannequinMaiu says "I managed to eat half a pie myself. That never happens!"
Traditional pumpkin pie
Antonia Johnston tells us that "at Thanksgiving nothing's greater than baking for family." Her pumpkin pie was also a big hit at dinner!
Traditional pumpkin pie
Jenn Marotta upped the ante and made a pumpkin chocolate ganache tart for our challenge. Wow!
Traditional pumpkin pie
Tanya of Fried Yellow Tomatoes made traditional pumpkin pie tarts with rum whipped cream (and a side of pecan tarts!).
Traditional pumpkin pie
snoball83 has fun in the kitchen, putting together a step-by-step as she made her pie for our challenge.
Traditional pumpkin pie
djbooyaka's gives us a close shot of her traditional pumpkin pie!
Traditional pumpkin pie
Michelle da Silva of Are You There Chef? It's Me, Michelle snaps a pic from above before digging in to this Thanksgiving treat.
Traditional pumpkin pie
Cindy Edwards Faita goes for simple elegance, setting her pie overtop a rustic plaid napkin.
Traditional pumpkin pie
Eve Kralik Rempel made her first ever pumpkin pie from scratch, topped with whipped cream and a dusting of spice. Yum!
Traditional pumpkin pie
Alisa Angelina is another first-timer making pumpkin pie, and it turned out great. We love the pecan garnish on top!
Traditional pumpkin pie
Olena Iryna's pumpkin pie gets it's close-up while cooling by the window at the cottage.
Traditional pumpkin pie
Jaun Harrow baked up a parade of pies, all with beautifully golden, decorated pastry!
Traditional pumpkin pie
Laura D made six miniature traditional pumpkin pies for her guests, so everyone got one of their own!
Traditional pumpkin pie
Viktoria Lagos' mini pumpkin-pie tarts get styled for their photo-shoot. Delicious!
Traditional pumpkin pie
Eve Yantha decorated the top of her traditional pie with arranged pastry leaves.
Shy-high pumpkin pie
Natasha Racco tells us her sky-high meringue "saluted Clooney and Bullock in space." She topped it with maple-glazed roasted pecans and a cinnamon-gingersnap dusting. Delicious!
Sky-high pumpkin pie
Deborah Adam of CCCulinista tells us "I finally broke in my kitchen torch after a year of waiting for the perfect recipe!"
Sarah Reynolds pumpkin pie
Sarah Reynolds tops her pumpkin pie with a shard of homemade pumpkin seed brittle — great idea!
Sky-high pumpkin pie
Tara sent in a pic of the sky-high pumpkin pie her husband whipped up for the holiday weekend!
Traditional pumpkin pie
Wanda snaps a quick shot of her pie, topped with a dollop of whipped cream. Yum!
Traditional pumpkin pie
Olena Iryna sets up a fun before and after of her pie. Wonder who was lucky enough to get the last slice?
The very best of Chatelaine straight to your inbox.
Chatelaine celebrates, inspires, informs and empowers. We know that Canadian women contain multitudes, and we cover all of the issues—big and small—that matter to them, from climate change to caregiving, Canadian fashion and what to cook now.
Subscribe to Chatelaine!
Want to streamline your life? In our Spring 2025 issue, we’ll show you how—whether it’s paring down your wardrobe, decluttering your messiest spaces or spending way less time cooking thanks to an easy, mostly make-ahead meal plan for busy weeknights. Plus, our first annual Pantry Awards.