Obviously Sophie's song isn't hip — it doesn't need to be

Sophie Grégoire-Trudeau performed an original song on Martin Luther King day. Out came the critics.
Obviously Sophie's song isn't hip  — it doesn't need to be
On Monday, in front of 200 people (including former Prime Minister Joe Clark), Sophie Grégoire-Trudeau broke into song. For most, public singing is relegated to the territory of their subconscious that produces anxiety dreams. But, in this case, the "where" was a Martin Luther King Day celebration at Ottawa’s City Hall. According to Grégoire-Trudeau — who was not the first of the day's musical guest speakers — she penned the song, entitled "Smile Back At Me," for her daughter, Ella-Grace, during a "difficult time" in her own life. Cynics have noses well-trained for shows of vulnerability, so media outlets and commenters immediately pounced, writing off Grégoire-Trudeau's impromptu ditty as a self-serving distraction from the country's bumpy economy. Toronto Star music columnist Ben Rayner even parsed Grégoire-Trudeau's musical prowess, saying she "failed to present any evidence that the song, such as it was, had any sort of formal structure or coherence." The serenade comes a mere two days after the New York Times condescendingly christened Canada "hip" — the most compelling reason for which was the election of Grégoire-Trudeau's husband, Justin Trudeau, better known as our congenial "world leader with a heart."

Related: The Trudeau "nannygate" scandal is just plain childish

Some will worry that we risk the Times revoking our cool card in light of Grégoire-Trudeau's MLK Day performance, demoting us, once again, to "hopelessly unstylish" status. Others will continue to deride her hyper-earnest Earth Mother persona. In fairness, she did compare Canadians to snowflakes in the same speech. But what do we gain from shaming a woman for divulging an intimate intergenerational moment with her daughter on a day intended to celebrate human rights? Also, anyone who's ever been a kid in a Christmas concert can attest to the blind terror of singing for an audience, and, as such, should be able to acknowledge Grégoire-Trudeau's move as a gutsy one. Seeing as we've become so allergic to emotional exposure — in politics; in general — maybe Grégoire-Trudeau's is the kind of necessary, if saccharine, correction to the fearful and divisive Canadian political landscape that fuelled Stephen Harper's final campaign. (And, lest we forget, the last PM also fronted a band.) For every deeply cool Cohen, Bieber and Drake that Canada's produced, remember that there is also a Dion, a Bublé and a Glass Tiger — all torchbearers of our country's penchant for naked effusiveness. So let Sophie have her moment in the spotlight — or at least give this dance remix a listen.
Related: That Sophie Grégoire-Trudeau song: Six things you might be wondering about What's behind Sophie Grégoire-Trudeau's new style Exclusive photos of the Trudeaus at home


Subscribe to our newsletters for our very best stories, recipes, style and shopping tips, horoscopes and special offers.

By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.