• Newsletters
  • Subscribe
Fitness

Are workouts based on fear sustainable?

Our fitness blogger James Fell looks at whether a near-death experience can act as a motivator for positive change.
Find something you love to do to motivate long-term health changes. Find something you love to do to motivate long-term health changes.

A recent study in the Journal of the American Medical Association showed that fear of death isn’t a great lifestyle motivator.

The study looked at the habits of 153,996 adults (aged 35 to 70) recently diagnosed with heart disease or having recently experience a stroke event. Based on smoking cessation, dietary changes and exercise adoption it found, “the prevalence of healthy lifestyle behaviours was low.” Only one-third adopted an exercise program at all.

Granted a health scare can be an initial impetus to start thinking about exercise (and adopting other healthy behaviours), it has no staying power. Changing the way you live your life just to stave off heart disease will get tiresome.

You must progress past fear, and quickly.

Advertisement

An interim step can be a sense of duty. Duty to yourself to live better, but also duty to others, like family, to stick around a little longer; to be healthier in order to fulfill your commitments as a parent and/or spouse, perhaps.

But even duty has its limits. Most people do things because they want to. Long-term adherence to any lifestyle is about finding something you love.

Passion is key. Fear may get you started, but to stick with an exercise program long term it’s important to start with an idea that you’re going to learn to embrace the good feelings that come along with it. This in turn may prevent the health scare in the first place.

If you want to ignite a positive change in your health, and more importantly, if you want to stick with it, you must learn to love the journey.

Advertisement

Get your FREE Weight Loss Report from James. 

The very best of Chatelaine straight to your inbox.

By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.

James S Fell, MBA, CSCS, authors the syndicated column "In-Your-Face Fitness" for the Chicago Tribune and Tribune Newspapers. He also does celebrity fitness interviews for the LA Times, and writes fitness columns for Chatelaine and AskMen. His first book on the subject of how to retrain your brain for sustainable weight loss is coming from Random House in 2013.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Copy link
The cover of the Chatelaine Summer 2025 issue, featuring a pink drink with a paper straw.

Subscribe to Chatelaine!

In our Summer 2025 issue, we get real about what sex is like after 40. Plus, living together after divorce, our favourite beauty products of the year and 17 incredibly summery recipes, from ceviche to sour cherry cobbler.