Advertisement
Recipes

11 Christmas Trifle And Pudding Recipes

These make-ahead desserts are true holiday crowd pleasers.
11 Christmas Trifle And Pudding Recipes

Black Forest trifle. (Photo: Erik Putz)

Trifles and large-format puddings were meant for parties: they're served from a single bowl, feed a crowd, and look fantastic on the table. Plus, they're best when made in advance, knocking at least one more item off your day-of holiday party to do list. Here's our favourite Christmas trifle and pudding recipes, from traditional flavours to some new holiday twists.

Black Forest Trifle

This decadent Black Forest trifle with cherries is a holiday party waiting to happen. It's easy to make ahead (and tastes even better the next day).
Get our black forest trifle recipe.

A trifle bowl showing layers of strawberry and lime curd trifle with pistachios on a turquoise table with a striped qhite and turquoise curtain in the background(Recipes by Donna Borooah; Produced by Aimee Nishitoba; Photography by Christie Vuong; Food styling by Eshun Mott; Prop styling by Madeleine Johari)

Cranberry And Clementine Eton Mess

Eton mess—kind of a cross between trifle and pavlova—makes the perfect sweet-tart-creamy-crunchy ending to a festive meal. Both the meringues and the saucy fruit can be made days ahead, so all you need to do is whip your cream and assemble your mess—either in individual bowls or glasses or on a platter, family-style—when you’re ready for it. Get our cranberry and clementine Eton mess recipe.

A person offering a tray of Cranberry and Clementine Eton Mess to a happy party guestProduced by Chantal Braganza and Sun Ngo, Photography by Christie Vuong, Prop Styling by Catherine Doherty, Food Styling by Eshun Mott.

Strawberry And Lime Curd Trifle

Tart lime curd and buttery pistachios add a pale green contrast to rosy strawberries and the pairing is reminiscent of those strawberry-kiwi-flavoured treats you enjoyed as a kid. Take the shortcut with store-bought angel food cake; this trifle is full of other homemade elements. Get our strawberry and lime curd trifle recipe.

Advertisement
11 Christmas Trifle And Pudding RecipesCake design by Brooke Cowitz, Produced by Chantal Braganza and Sun Ngo, Photography by Christie Vuong, Prop Styling by Madeleine Johari, Food Styling by Michelle Lucas Larving

No Bake Raspberry Trifle

Bust out your best novelty glassware: This no-bake trifle recipe from the 1990s remains unchanged and as delicious as ever. Get our no-bake raspberry trifle recipe. 

Lemon meringue triflePhoto, Roberto Caruso.

Lemon Meringue Trifle

Our twist on classic trifle sparkles with fruit. Since it tastes better if refrigerated overnight, you only have to dollop on whipped cream before serving.

Looking for a great make-ahead desert? This lemon meringue trifle recipe improves over time as the ladyfingers soak in the limoncello & lemon juice. Get our lemon meringue trifle recipe. 

Cranberry-Mandarin Trifle

Our twist on classic trifle sparkles with fruit. Since it tastes better if refrigerated overnight, you only have to dollop on whipped cream before serving. Get our cranberry mandarin recipe here.

A bowl of sticky toffee pudding on a table beside a pitcher of brandy glaze beside the pan with the entire pudding, sticky toffee pudding recipe(Photo: Roberto Caruso)

Sticky Toffee Pudding

A classic British dessert, allegedly made popular in the 1970s by Francis Coulson, chef at Sharrow Bay Country House in northern England. (No matter its origins, this deluxe moist spongey cake with caramel and creamy custard sauce will please every sweet tooth.) Get our sticky toffee pudding recipe.  

Advertisement
Christmas pudding with brandy-butter sauce on a white stand, Christmas pudding recipe(Photo, Erik Putz.)

Christmas Pudding With Brandy-Butter Sauce

Drizzled with a rich sauce, this luxurious pudding is the perfect way to cap off a traditional roast beef dinner over the holidays. Get our Christmas pudding with brandy-butter sauce recipe. 

mincemeat pudding muffinsMincemeat pudding muffins. (Photo, Erik Putz.)

Christmas Pudding Muffins

This isn't your grandma's plum pudding: Our incredibly moist minis can be made days in advance, then reheated in the microwave.

Individual servings of this Christmas classic? Yes, please. Get our Christmas pudding muffins recipe.

Cranberry Sticky Pudding

Our incredibly moist minis can be made days in advance, then reheated in the microwave. Get our cranberry sticky pudding recipe.

A banana pudding dessert served in a trifle dish alongside glass plates and utensilsProduced by Stephanie Han Kim, Photo by Christie Vuong, Food Styling by Sage Dakota, Prop Styling by Andrea McCrindle.

Banana Pudding

This ridiculously delicious dessert is the perfect marriage of from-scratch and store bought components. After chilling, the cookies become soft enough to scoop, but still have a bit of bite. Get our banana pudding recipe. 

Advertisement

Ginger-Berry Cookies And Cream Trifle

This dessert was inspired by English trifle, but we riffed on the classic to make it easier, quicker and a bit more chic. Add a splash of sherry to the berries for an extra flavour hit. Get our ginger-berry cookies and cream trifle recipe.

Ginger-berry cookies and cream trifle topped with raspberries and blueberries in a trifle bowl with a bite taken out to reveal ginger wafers and whipped cream(Photo: Angus Fergusson)
 
Assorted cookies on a pink background with the words in white "Find more Christmas cookie recipes"

GET CHATELAINE IN YOUR INBOX!

Subscribe to our newsletters for our very best stories, recipes, style and shopping tips, horoscopes and special offers.

By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

The Editorial Team of Chatelaine magazine.

Advertisement
Advertisement